Centralforce666 said:
I really need to point out that the advice that you lack yang energy is very incorrect...
The root cause is obstruction of yang energy due to phlegm and heat congestion NOT deficiency.
I suspect that building your yang energy will only get you so far.
When you're ready to address the actual cause, please respond to my prior questions.
Please also note I mean no disrespect to anyone answering questions here, but a Chinese Medicine Doctor, I cannot simply let incorrect diagnosis be taken as gospel, this is someone's health we are talking about.
The advice that I gave to him was based largely on my own experiences and from the advice that I got from advanced members. I had made few posts asking for advice for the exact same condition as he has now. For example:
https://ancient-forums.com/viewtopic.php?p=276939#p276939
On the above topic, Blackdragon666 himself had advised me to do a mercury square for my health which is same as his. Although my diagnosis might have been incorrect, the advice that I gave to him isn't without basis.
Besides, it is not his first time being recommended to do sun or mars squares or use related planetary runes for his problem. He had already made another post where Blitzkreig had advised him to do squares or affiliated planetary runes of sun or mars.
Although he had said that it will fix his bodily energy and had not necessarily pronounced the the square's relationship with his sinusitis, this citation is still valid in challenging your statement that "I suspect that building your yang energy will only get you so far."
Regarding the context of the said post, Blitzkreig had quoted and advised sun and mars energies via both squares and runes to Goldenxchild when the complaint was constant clogging of sinuses and inability to breathe from the nose resulting in higher proportion of time spent on mouth breathing.
Here:
https://ancient-forums.com/viewtopic.php?p=339640#p339640
Saulo is similar to the Sun, and Thurisaz is similar to Mars, so both can work here. Yet, both those planets are available within Square formats. Using the Squares in a general sense, to simply boost the associated planet, should be enough to fix your bodily energy, especially with these other changes.
In another post, once again, I was advised to focus on squares for permanent solution to my Asthma.
https://ancient-forums.com/viewtopic.php?p=332503#p332503
Note that in the post above, I was only advised for asthma, but not for sinusitis. Although my memory is vague and I might be wrong but a doctor once told me that generally people who have asthma also have sinus related problems. Of course, I can't cite such vague memories. So, I will directly quote some websites:
https://www.thewellnessseeker.com/connection-between-rhinitis-acid-reflux-sinusitis-asthma/
People who have asthma are more likely to suffer from chronic sinusitis and patients with sinusitis are much more likely to develop asthma.
Another link:
https://www.jaxallergy.com/sinusitis-and-asthma-connection/
Although, Blitzkreig had only advised me to focus on planets for permanent spiritual solutions for my asthma, I theorize that even my sinusitis would be permanently cured had I focused on planets as he had advised since these two conditions are said to be interlinked as suggested by the websites above. You might argue that he had not actually advised me to do squares. In that case, directly quoting what he said:
Take note of the planets I mentioned for more permanent solutions to both your vitality and asthma, as well.
The planets he had mentioned in his post:
As far as Squares go, the Sun and Mars rule over vitality. Mercury rules over wind conditions and the lungs, whereas Venus rules over what seems to be heat conditions of the blood.
Another citation citing relationship between yang energy deficiency and dampness/phlegm.
https://ancient-forums.com/viewtopic.php?p=352290#p352290
This same problem can occur in people with yang deficiencies like if you are overworked, not sleeping enough, have poor Sun/Mars energies, and so on. All of these things will result in dampness/phlegm buildup in the body.
What makes this worse is inflammation, which can prevent the body from easily clearing out these other pathogens
I believe that dampness and phlegm buildup in his body is exactly what he is suffering from. I stand corrected when you say that it is due to congestion
too. That said, all of the citation above clarify the relationship between
deficiency of mars/yang/sun energies and dampness. Therefore, I completely disagree with the statement that:
The root cause is obstruction of yang energy due to phlegm and heat congestion NOT deficiency.
I suspect that building your yang energy will only get you so far.
Of course, I will not deny congestion to be
one of the causes. However, I disagree in the statement that it is the primary and root cause and that yang deficiency does not have much relevancy in being one of the major causes. That, building yang energies won't get him far which is false since the citations above clearly indicate the relationship between deficiency of yang and dampness/phlegm.
but a Chinese Medicine Doctor, I cannot simply let incorrect diagnosis be taken as gospel,
I stand corrected by you in my incorrect diagnosis. It was my fault and ignorance in diagnosing as such. However, I will firmly stand by the advice that I gave to him for treating his condition. I have already provided the citations above on clarifying exactly on what basis that I advised as such to him.
That said, you have weird parameters on defining the integrity of your title. When I made the same exact post asking for advice for the same exact condition as his and for which Blitzkreig himself told me to await your guidance, where exactly did you disappear to ? Where exactly did the integrity of your title which you so uphold highly and with dignity disappear to ? Was it because I disrespected you by messing up the quotes ? Does such a mistake completely warrant the ceasing of treatment of patient ? Was my health of not much significance to you or was I not 'someone' to you ? Had you diagnosed me, perhaps I could have been spared 2 years of suffering from my chronic sinusitis and asthma. Although, I do not have much faith in any physical treatment now considering the many physical solutions that I tried to apply as highlighted in my above post which included but was not limited to 10 sessions of needle acupuncture therapy.
Of course, you have helped in curing conditions of many members here and just the above cannot invalidate your work. It is just me letting out my frustration and grievance. Countless people whom you have treated in the forums would disagree with me and they would be right in doing so. I do hope that you continue in prescribing treatment as you have done before as you are highly skilled,experienced and knowledgeable. The only basis with which I argued above with such a quality doctor has much more to do with my own experience than the general advice given. Had it not been for that, it would merely be a child trying to argue with an adult to gain his/her attention and waste time.
Ahem, GoldenxChild, do follow any treatment plan that he prescribes. He is very highly experienced and respected by even Blitzkreig himself. I cannot compare to him in any magnitude, be it his knowledge or experience. You would do well to follow what he prescribed diligently. That said, the things that I have advised you are not harmful. Along with his treatment plan, I do emphasize on doing the squares. Even if the square does not work(Highly unlikely), added increase in health and general vitality from it is always worth the time spent on completing it.
I do hope that you are free from your condition by diligently following what he prescribes according to your condition and from the squares. I myself did not have such opportunity but do hope that you are treated with appropriate attention and guidance. I might not reply to either you and him after this as I am busy with something important but will reply if it concerns your treatment.
Take care and good luck.