NinRick said:
slyscorpion said:
People have to be careful but it would be harder than you think to reconstruct an entire chart btw. Even a professional astrologer would have difficulty or not even be able to do that with just a few clues most people who talk about this on here give. I would assume most posts where someone gives too much information are not approved in my case that has happened a couple times and I have been much more careful.
However knowing and discussing someones element or even a few planetary placements or like I say my Ascendant. There is no way anyone can reconstruct a full chart with this. I never revealed even the year I was born.
If someone wants to be careful yet ask about something really specific they can say "I have a friend who has this or I know someone with such a placement" there is no way anyone would know.
If you give information about a slow moving planet like Neptune, a fast moving planet like Venus und something even faster like your asc or another house, everyone could reconstruct your chart pretty easy, and accurate enough to know your rulers and thus be able to curse you
True I get your point This is why someone has to be careful on giving out degrees on things. I haven't really seen anyone do that much unless they are asking about something on a negative degree of conjunct a star.
But this could be bad I see your point. Maybe people should be warned about this more. Cause most people wouldn't think of this I mean I didn't.
But it could be bad if someone said they have Their Neptune or Uranus conjunct Antares for example and then go to say they are Leo ascendant just an example I made up and they then ask about Venus conjunct something else. Then especially if they have another house position they can recreate a chart I see your point.
Then if someone has another house they can get a chart right there