No offense taken my bro, I was just suprised as the way you stated that vedic astrology is inaccurate made me think that there was already a major debate about this in the past with a decisive result and now this is common knowledge on the boards.
Personally I studied both system and decided to master the vedic system because It precisely showed my weaknesess (health, persona and spiritual wise) and the sources of these weaknesess from multiple reference points - which I could not see In my western chart. Based on this I was able to construct a program for healing and applied other vedic astrological principles in practice and I was shocked how well it worked. It was not an ego issue for me as on a superficial level my vedic chart appears significantly weaker. I don't want to waste any further space to the topic of Vedic Astrology, I will create a post and show the main principles through analyising the chart of Adolf Hitler. In this i will also reply on your anwser here. (About not using generational planets etc.)